Does slow, no-relaxation lifting at 50% 1RM build muscle after 60?
In 35 adults aged 59-76, 12 weeks twice weekly raised thigh muscle thickness and knee strength; normal speed at that load added little size. Abstract only.
Watanabe and colleagues tested whether the slow, no-relaxation lifting style (LST) developed in young men also grows muscle in older people when the load is held constant.
Thirty-five men and women aged 59-76 were randomly assigned to knee extension and knee flexion at 50% of 1RM, either LST (3 s eccentric, 3 s concentric, 1 s isometric, no rest between repetitions) or normal speed (1 s concentric, 1 s eccentric, 1 s rest between repetitions), twice a week for 12 weeks (2 weeks of preparation and 10 weeks of intervention).
LST significantly increased thigh muscle thickness and isometric knee extension and flexion strength. Normal-speed training also improved strength significantly but had only a limited effect on muscle size. The authors conclude that LST is effective for gaining muscle mass and strength even in older people.
How this relates to the Russian static-dynamic method: the closest tested form in older adults: the load is fixed at 50% 1RM in both groups, so the comparison isolates the slow, no-relaxation style (with whatever change in effort it brings) against intermittent normal-speed lifting. Sets, repetitions, rest between sets, range and failure are not in the abstract. No oxidative, mitochondrial or capillary outcome.
Protocol
Key Results
| Outcome (12 wk) | LST, 50% 1RM slow, no relaxation | LN, 50% 1RM normal speed |
|---|---|---|
| Thigh muscle thickness | significant increase | limited effect (per the authors) |
| Isometric knee extension strength | significant increase | significant improvement in strength |
| Isometric knee flexion strength | significant increase | significant improvement in strength |
| Numbers and between-group tests | not in the abstract |
Mechanisms
Practical Application
Limitations
How this entry was checked and changed
(from the abstract) — parallel RCT with 35 (rubric B+: 20-39); no numbers, dropouts or between-group statistics in the abstract