REF-1612 · Gearhart et al., 2004 · Perceptual and Motor Skills · Paper · PubMed

Learning the Borg scale from verbal instructions alone or while riding a maximal test made no clear difference to ratings during a 30-s all-out cycle sprint: 30 recreationally trained young men in three groups of 10 (instructions only; the same instructions given during a maximal graded test, with the top of the scale set at its last stage or at a 30-s sprint straight after) gave similar ratings, slopes and intercepts. Small, old, no numbers in the abstract

Main caveat: Abstract only; no values, spread or statistics.
limited, mixed evidenceMeasured on recreational to trained athletesRead from the abstract only

Gearhart and colleagues compared three ways of teaching the 15-category Borg scale before a 30-s maximal cycle sprint against a resistance of 0.10 × body mass (kg). One group of 10 had verbal instructions only (a memory anchor).

Two groups had the same instructions delivered while riding a maximal graded test: the low anchor was set during light pedalling, and the high anchor at the final stage of the test in one group and at a 30-s sprint right after it in the other. Ratings were taken at 8, 13, 18, 23 and 28 s of the experimental sprint.

The authors report that ratings, and the slopes and intercepts of their regressions over the sprint, were similar across the three groups, and conclude that memory anchoring and combined exercise-and-memory anchoring give similar ratings in short, high-intensity cycling in young recreationally trained athletes.

Participants

n = 30 recreationally trained men, 10 per group. Age, fitness and cycling background are not in the abstract.

Protocol

Memory group: verbal instructions only, before the trial.
Exercise-memory group 1: the same instructions during a maximal graded cycle test; low anchor in light pedalling, high anchor at the test's final stage.
Exercise-memory group 2: as group 1, with the high anchor set during a 30-s sprint straight after the graded test.
Trial: 30 s of maximal pedalling at 0.10 × body mass (kg); Borg 6-20 at 8, 13, 18, 23 and 28 s.

Key Results

Ratings were similar among the three groups.
Linear regression slopes and intercepts of rating over time were also similar.
Not in the abstract: the ratings themselves, their spread, test statistics, p-values, and whether any test of equivalence was made.

Practical Application

In 30 recreationally trained young men, learning the Borg scale from verbal instructions alone gave similar ratings in a 30-s all-out cycle sprint to learning it while riding a maximal test, so for that effort adding a lab maximal test made no clear difference. With groups of 10 and no numbers reported, it shows no clear difference rather than proof of sameness, and only for a short sprint.
For someone who finds rating hard, a careful verbal explanation of the ends of the scale did as well here as anchoring them on the bike (the abstract does not give the wording of the instructions); the lifting review found the same for mean ratings, with an exercise anchor steadying ratings over the first two sessions (REF-1608).
Inference, not tested here: in long submaximal rides anchoring may matter differently (in REF-1611 ratings at the same lactate were higher in longer graded tests, not shown within long rides); no study in the base tests it.
No group in this study went without anchoring, so it cannot say whether instructions matter at all.

Limitations

Abstract only; no values, spread or statistics.
Ten per group; allocation method not stated; no equivalence test reported.
Men only, young, recreationally trained; one 30-s sprint.
Published 2004; no newer cycling test of anchoring was found for the base.
No un-anchored comparison group.
How this entry was checked and changed
Why this level

a small parallel comparison (10 per group) is B by design; one step down because only the abstract was read, which does not say whether groups were randomised and gives no ratings, statistics or equivalence test, so "similar" from three groups of 10 cannot rule out a real difference