After both a 25-min and a 90-min afternoon nap opportunity, every performance measure was at its worst in the first 30 min after waking (sleep inertia, deeper after the 90-min nap); most measures had improved by 60-90 min after waking, and at 90-120 min the 90-min nap beat no nap and the 25-min nap on sleepiness, fatigue, decision reaction time and grip, in a randomised crossover of 17 physically active young adults (abstract only; no effect sizes in the abstract)
Boukhris and colleagues tested how long the grogginess after a daytime nap (sleep inertia) lasts and whether it depends on nap length. Seventeen physically active young adults each completed three afternoons in random, counterbalanced order: no nap, a 25-min nap opportunity and a 90-min nap opportunity in a laboratory sleep pod.
Night sleep before each session was tracked with an actigraph and nap sleep with a forehead EEG device. From 15:00 they completed four 30-min test batteries spanning the first two hours after the nap: sleepiness, fatigue and readiness to perform, a vigilance task and a Simon (decision) task, handgrip strength and a countermovement jump.
In the first block (0-30 min after the nap) every performance measure was worse than in the later blocks after both nap lengths, and the dip was deeper after the 90-min nap for sleepiness, readiness, handgrip and decision accuracy.
By the third block (60-90 min) most performance measures had improved after both naps (the abstract does not say whether against no nap or against the first block), and in the fourth block (90-120 min) the 90-min nap beat both no nap and the 25-min nap for sleepiness, fatigue, decision reaction time and handgrip.
The authors conclude that sleep inertia needs at least an hour to clear after either nap length, with gains appearing 1-2 h after napping.
Participants
Protocol
Key Results
| Comparison | Finding (abstract) |
|---|---|
| T1 (0-30 min after the nap) vs T2-T4, both nap lengths | all performance markers impaired at T1 (p < 0.05) |
| N90 vs N25 at T1 | deeper sleep inertia after N90 for sleepiness, readiness to perform, handgrip and Simon-task accuracy (p < 0.05) |
| N25 and N90 at T3 (60-90 min) | most performance markers improved (p < 0.05); comparator not stated in the abstract |
| N90 vs NN and N25 at T4 (90-120 min) | larger improvement after N90 in sleepiness, fatigue, Simon-task reaction time and handgrip (p < 0.05) |
Practical Application
Limitations
How this entry was checked and changed
a crossover of 17 (the rubric's B+ band for crossovers of 15 or more) held at B: the abstract gives P values only, no means, effect sizes or variability, and not the sleep obtained in each nap; performance tasks, not markers