Does HIIT block muscle building when I also lift?
In 19 untrained young men protein synthesis and type II fibre size rose with or without it, but strength rose less with it (P = 0.016). Markers, small trial; abstract only.
Conceição and colleagues randomised 19 previously untrained young men to concurrent or resistance training for 16 weeks.
Biopsies were taken before and 48 h after a standardised session at weeks 4 and 16, with myofibrillar protein synthesis measured by deuterium oxide incorporation, along with satellite cells, myonuclei and gene expression; strength, aerobic capacity and fibre cross-sectional area were measured at baseline and after training.
Protein synthesis rose 48 h after exercise at both time points with no group differences. Type II fibres grew and myonuclei increased; strength gains were greater with resistance training alone, and aerobic capacity improved only with concurrent training.
The authors conclude that concurrent training did not inhibit the molecular mechanisms associated with hypertrophy in untrained people. Our reading: that closing sentence is narrower than the title and is the fair one. Protein synthesis is a marker, not performance. A non-significant group difference in a trial of 19 across two groups is weak evidence of no difference.
And the outcome the athlete actually lifts with went the other way.
Protocol
Key Results
| Outcome | Result as reported | P |
|---|---|---|
| Muscle protein synthesis, 48 h after exercise, weeks 4 and 16 | Increased; no group differences | 0.0105 (over time) |
| Satellite cell content | Increased over time in type II fibres only | 0.0021 |
| Myonuclear number, type I / type II fibres | Increased in both | 0.0301 / 0.0009 |
| Myonuclear number, type I | Higher in the concurrent group | 0.0027 |
| MYF5 / MYF6 expression | Increased over time | 0.0141 / 0.034 |
| MYOD1 expression | Elevated after exercise only in concurrent | 0.0009 |
| Type II fibre size | Increased | 0.016 |
| Strength gains | Greater with resistance training alone | 0.016 |
| Aerobic capacity (VO2peak) | Improved only with concurrent | < 0.001 |
Mechanisms
Practical Application
Limitations
How this entry was checked and changed
a parallel RCT under 20 is B; held at B- under the rubric because this is an abstract-only small study whose headline outcomes are markers (protein synthesis, satellite cells, gene expression), not what an athlete performs, and key methods, group sizes and between-group effect sizes are unread