Does cutting carbohydrate after a double add signal?
Nine men: no clear difference in four muscle signals at about 12 or 3 g/kg, and a bone-resorption marker higher on the low diets. One day, markers only, every arm trained twice.
Nine men ran 8 × 5 min at 85% VO2peak in the morning and again in the afternoon, 3.5 h between sessions, under three diets: high carbohydrate (HCHO, about 12 g/kg, energy availability about 60 kcal/kg fat-free mass), reduced carbohydrate with high fat (LCHF, about 3 g/kg, about 60 kcal/kg) and reduced carbohydrate with reduced energy (LCAL, about 3 g/kg, about 20 kcal/kg).
Glycogen fell to about 200 mmol/kg dry weight straight after the afternoon session in all three arms, then stood at 171, 194 and 316 mmol/kg dry weight 17 h later, lower in both restricted arms than in HCHO.
The signalling readouts rose with exercise and showed comparable responses across arms. βCTX after exercise was lower in HCHO than in the other two, and the exercise rise in IL-6 was larger in LCAL than in the other two.
The authors conclude that, with glycogen kept at 200-350 mmol/kg dry weight, restricting carbohydrate and energy for under a day after exercise does not add to these signals, while carbohydrate around the sessions blunts a marker of bone resorption.
Our reading: useful against the idea that restriction of this depth after a double buys extra signal at the time points sampled, and it fits the idea that a low glycogen threshold matters more than the restriction itself. It does not show what happens over weeks.
Protocol
Key Results
| Measure | HCHO | LCHF | LCAL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carbohydrate (g/kg) | ~12 | ~3 | ~3 |
| Energy availability (kcal/kg fat-free mass) | ~60 | ~60 | ~20 |
| Glycogen straight after the afternoon session (mmol/kg dw) | ~200 | ~200 | ~200 |
| Glycogen at 17 h (mmol/kg dw; read in the order LCHF, LCAL, HCHO of the sentence) | 316 | 171 | 194 |
| p38MAPK phosphorylation after the afternoon session | rose | rose, comparable | rose, comparable |
| PGC-1α, p53, CPT1 mRNA | rose | rose, comparable | rose, comparable |
| βCTX after exercise | lower (P < 0.05) | higher than HCHO | higher than HCHO |
| IL-6 rise with exercise | smaller than LCAL | smaller than LCAL | larger (P < 0.05) |
Mechanisms
Practical Application
Limitations
How this entry was checked and changed
(from the abstract) — mechanistic laboratory study with no performance outcome, in the rubric's own words. No copy in PubMed Central or Europe PMC, so biopsy timing, diet delivery and exact effect sizes were not read