A heavy circuit (6RM, about 35 s between sets) built the same bench press and half-squat 1RM, bench press power and lean mass as the same sets with 3-min rests in 33 resistance-trained men over 8 weeks, in shorter sessions; only the long-rest group raised 30-s Wingate peak power, and only the circuit group lowered % body fat
Alcaraz and colleagues asked whether a heavy-load circuit, which shortens the rest between sets, brings the same adaptations as traditional strength training with long rests.
Thirty-three healthy men were randomised to a high-resistance circuit (HRC: 3-6 sets of 6 exercises at 6RM, about 35 s between sets), traditional strength training (TS: the same sets and loads with 3 min between sets) or a control group; both training groups lifted three times a week for 8 weeks.
Before and after, the authors tested bench press and half squat 1RM, bench press peak power, body composition by DXA, a shuttle run and a 30-s Wingate test. Both training groups raised upper- and lower-limb 1RM to the same extent, produced more bench press peak power across loads (p ≤ 0.01), ran the shuttle better and gained lean mass but not bone mass.
Wingate peak power rose only after TS (p ≤ 0.05), and % body fat fell only after HRC. The authors conclude that HRC gives a strength and mass adaptation similar to traditional training while taking less session time.
Participants
Protocol
Key Results
| Outcome | HRC (about 35-s rests) | TS (3-min rests) |
|---|---|---|
| Bench press and half squat 1RM | increased | increased; equal to HRC |
| Bench press peak power, several loads | higher (p ≤ 0.01) | higher (p ≤ 0.01) |
| Shuttle run | better | better |
| 30-s Wingate peak power | no significant rise | increased (p ≤ 0.05) |
| % body fat | decreased | no significant change |
| Lean mass | increased | increased |
| Bone mass | no increase | no increase |
Practical Application
Limitations
How this entry was checked and changed
parallel RCT, 33 in three arms (11 per arm by the rubric's division; group sizes not in the abstract); the abstract gives directions and p thresholds, no group means or effect sizes